Weatherford Democrat

Big Story AM

July 27, 2011

Homeowners file suit

Judge rules out district court for tax suit involving Aledo, Willow Park residents

WEATHERFORD — Judge Trey Loftin has granted a plea to the jurisdiction on behalf of local taxing entities, ruling that the 43rd District Court has no authority to hear a case involving Aledo and Willow Park homeowners claiming an illegal assessment of back taxes.

The case is a counterclaim to a lawsuit first filed in March by the City of Willow Park to collect delinquent taxes from Todd Brennan and Valerie Smith.

The counterclaim has been leveled by attorney Josh Carden on behalf of the owners of 13 properties against the cities of Willow Park and Aledo, the Parker County Appraisal District, the Parker County Appraisal Review Board and Chief Appraiser Larry Hammonds.

Loftin’s ruling has stymied efforts to expand the case to a class-action lawsuit that could represent hundreds of residents of Willow Park Village, Stone Bluff of Aledo and Fairview Addition, who were told — in 2008 ­— to pay about $300,000 in back taxes for the tax years dating from 2003 to 2007.

“All the counterclaims we’ve filed are dismissed,” Carden said, “but the good news is ... [the ruling] will accelerate the case; it is an accelerated appeal.”

Carden said he will go before the 2nd Court of Appeals in Fort Worth and, if necessary, the Supreme Court of Texas.

Fort Worth attorney Barbara Williams, representing the cities of Aledo and Willow Park along with Fort Worth firm Taylor, Olson, Adkins, Sralla & Elam, L.L.P., said that most of the residents have already paid their taxes.

She said she expected Loftin’s ruling, which she views as a victory, but said there would have been an appeal either way.

“There is a Supreme Court case on point,” she said, “that says if a taxpayer does not utilize the administrative procedures detailed in the Tax Code there is no jurisdiction.”

Loftin’s ruling fell in line with that 2006 case, Williams said, similar because taxpayers did not follow tax code procedures, which call for first lodging a protest with the Appraisal Review Board.

“They should have gone to the ARB, then filed suit in district court,” she said. “Instead, they waited until we filed suit, then used it as a defense to our suit to collect the delinquent tax.”

One of Carden’s claims is that Larry Hammonds, in his role as tax assessor/collector for the cities, didn’t operate within the bounds of the Texas Tax Code when he mailed tax bills to residents before going to the ARB.

Hammonds is being represented by Austin attorney Judith Hargrove, along with the appraisal district and appraisal review board.

“Hammonds had no authority to take that action,” Carden said. “Those were not taxes ... they were pieces of paper.”

“As a result there are cases that say that the assessor/collector is not subject to the ARB, not reviewable,” Carden said, “so the district courts have default.”

“I believe that Judge Loftin has jurisdiction because this case falls outside the regulatory framework of the tax code ­— which is normally dealt with by the Appraisal Review Board,” he said.

Williams disagrees.

“I think Mr. Hammond’s actions are totally within the bounds of the tax code,” she said. “I think he’s representing it to the letter.”

In addition to calling Hammond’s actions into account, the lawsuit alleges that the cities were not valid taxing units from 2003 to 2007 because they didn’t notify the appraisal district that their boundaries had expanded to include the three subdivisions.

It notes that the homeowners did receive and pay tax bills from the Aledo ISD and Parker County during the same time period.

Neither Carden nor Williams were willing to predict when the conflict would be resolved.

The taxing entities may view Loftin’s ruling as a victory “at this level,” Carden said, “but right now, they have won one battle in the struggle.”

1
Text Only
Big Story AM
  • thorp.jpg County treasurer dies of apparent heart attack

    The death of Parker County Treasurer Jim Thorp came suddenly Tuesday. Thorp, 50, died of an apparent heart attack early Tuesday afternoon after walking into Tri Cities Urgent Care Clinic in Willow Park with chest pains where he collapsed, staff at the treasurer’s office have confirmed.

    March 27, 2013 1 Photo

  • Brock ISD enters lawsuit

    At least one Parker County school is waging war against the state in response to a cut in public school financing.
    Brock ISD board members recently approved a resolution with the Equity Center to file a lawsuit against the state’s inequitable public school finance plan.

    September 30, 2011

  • City denies WLL request

    Within the same hour, the Weatherford City Council approved the 2011-12 budget and turned down a request from the Weatherford Little League for the city to take out a $500,000 loan.

    September 28, 2011

  • 0927 one end budget tax rate.jpg Commissioners raise tax rate

    Despite a packed courtroom and the protests of more than 20 residents, Parker County commissioners gave final approval Monday night to a $35,692,247 general fund budget for fiscal 2012 that bumps the current tax rate up two cents — from 24 cents/$100 assessed valuation to 26 cents per $100 valuation — while preserving generous health care benefits for county employees.
    The budget is up from last year’s $34,518,166, a 3.4 percent increase.

    September 27, 2011 1 Photo

  • IMG_5380.jpg Our town is tops

    Historical homes, horses and the proximity to Fort Worth and Dallas are all listed as reasons why Weatherford made the cut as one of the top 25 places to retire in the United States.

    September 23, 2011 1 Photo

  • Bailey, Kamden.jpg History of neglect

    The half-brother of Kamden Bailey — the 1-year-old, law enforcement claims, was killed by his mother’s boyfriend last week — was removed from his mother’s custody in 2008 due to neglect, court records show.

    September 21, 2011 1 Photo

  • Burned home Severely injured wreck victim loses home to fire

    Millsap resident Amanda “Mandy” Kiles-Williams has been in the intensive care unit fighting for her life since a head-on collision Thursday that crushed her car and left her severely injured.
    Nobody had told her as of Monday, but Kiles-Williams lost everything she owned Saturday in a fire that destroyed the home she shared with her brother and 16-year-old son.

    September 20, 2011 1 Photo

  • Putting in their two cents worth

    With 15 days until the budget filing deadline, county commissioners finally chose a direction Thursday, voting to proceed with Judge Mark Riley’s proposed general fund budget as a working document, with the exception of employee health care benefits, which are still in flux.
    The $35.6 million proposed general fund budget ­— up from $34.8 million last year — operates with a tax rate of 26 cents per $100 property valuation, up from 24 cents this year. The rate is the effective rate, which means it will generate the same amount of revenue for the county as last year when applied to this year’s lower property valuations.

    September 16, 2011

  • 0915 one Goparmelo, Oscar.tif Area man charged in stabbing

    A 33-year-old man was booked into the Parker County jail Tuesday on a warrant for aggravated assault with a deadly weapon after an alleged May stabbing.

    September 15, 2011 1 Photo

  • Plat office cut

    County commissioners, looking for $2 million in cuts to the 2011-12 budget, abolished the platting office in a 3-2 vote Tuesday, recovering the $74,000 salary of the office’s one employee as a first step.
    Judge Mark Riley and commissioners John Roth and Dusty Renfro voted in favor of the cut; commissioners George Conley and Craig Peacock voted against it.

    September 14, 2011

Must Read
Top News
House Ads
AP Video
Joy Fills Streets of Cleveland As LeBron Returns Proposed Bill to Regulate NY Costumed Characters WH: LeBron's Move a 'Powerful Statement' Ana Ortiz on 'Devious Maids' Finale CDC Addresses Lab Safety Problems Texas Shooting Suspect Collapses in Court Death Toll Tops 100 As Israel Offense Continues LeBron James Says He's Returning to Cavaliers Man Flees Police in World Cup Scalping Scheme Robot Writes Jewish Torah Scroll Raw: Israel, Gaza Exchange Rocket Fire More Immigrants Detained Along Rio Grande World Cup Final Pits Argentina Against Germany Police: Prostitute Linked to 2nd Death Thousands Attend NYC Firefighter's Funeral Art of Haitian Machete Fighting Revived Raw: Australia Hosts Annual Beer Can Regatta Mass. Mayor: Families Lost Everything in Fire Fans Dying to Be Near Jazz Greats Robots Gearing Up for Their Own 'World Cup'