Weatherford Democrat


August 27, 2012

COLUMN: Religious book isn't about fabrication, it's about faith

— This article is in response to Dennis Tilly’s “Column: Religious book seems to be fiction,” (Aug. 17 Viewpoints). In this column, Dennis mentions that he purchased a Book of Mormon and two books written by Mormon critics. Many of the arguments which he makes are very understandable since he has relied upon the critics of Mormonism. A couple of sources that I recommend as alternative points of view are: (and, and

Dennis has stated, “The problem with Smith’s New World history is that there are absolutely no archaeological artifacts of Israelite tribes in the New World.”

I shall indicate what I believe are some of the evidences of the Book of Mormon and the divine calling of Joseph Smith. We should remember that the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Shall we reject the Bible because some biblical narratives such as the Israelite presence in Egypt can’t be confirmed at this time?

I think that for Mormons as well as for other Christians, the primary source of gospel conviction or knowing the things of the spirit should be the prompting of the Holy Spirit, i.e. the Spirit of Truth bearing witness to our spirit that what we have read or heard is true. This is how the apostles such as Peter knew that Jesus was the Christ. This is not so say that archaeology and other knowledge are not important, but we should recognize their limitations. For one, they can’t answer the important questions of life such as why are we here?, or whether or not Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God.

I wish that I had the time to address one by one the issues that you have raised. You have stated, “I hope some reader will do their own factual research and if they disagree with my statements, please submit a column to the Democrat.” I thank you for this opportunity. I could probably provide better examples to share with you but these are some of the items that immediately come to mind.

Some of the evidences for Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon include the following:

1. In the front of every Book of Mormon is the “Testimony of the Three Witnesses” and the “Testimony of the Eight Witnesses.” The three witnesses had a spiritual witness in which they were shown the golden plates by an angel of God. The eight witnesses had a “physical” witness in which they were shown the golden plates by Joseph Smith but no angel was present. Even though some of these witness left the church and had opportunities to deny their testimony, never did they deny their testimonies as recorded in the front of the Book of Mormon.

2. Joseph Smith was a farm boy with very little formal education. The sheer speed in which he translated the book (approximately two months), the fact that Joseph never went back to correct it, and the internal consistency of the book is a miracle in itself. His wife, knowing of his lack of education and writing abilities, testified that Joseph could not have written such a book unless by divine power.

3. Joseph Smith taught that the “golden” plates (from which the Book of Mormon was translated) were buried in a stone box in a hill. At the time of Joseph Smith, both the idea of ancient writings on metal plates and records being preserved in stone boxes were considered ridiculous. However, we now have many examples of ancient metal writings and stone boxes.

4. Barley is mentioned several times in the Book of Mormon. One criticism has been that barley never grew in the New World until the white man brought it here. However, the December 1983 issues of Science83 reported the discovery in Arizona of what appears to be domesticated pre-columbian barley. In addition, biologist Howard Stutz has indicated that three types of wild barley have long been known to be native to the Americas.

5. Chiasmus is a poetical form used by many Near East languages. Chiasmus uses inverted parallelism. This poetical form wasn’t properly understood and acknowledged until the 1960’s. Complex chiasmus has recently been discovered in the Book of Mormon. Did Joseph translate records of a people that migrated from the Near East or did this farm boy with little formal education just happen to add these Near East poetical structures into the Book of Mormon?

6. Alma 7:10 (in the BofM) states that Jesus Christ “shall be born of Mary, at Jerusalem which is the land of our forefathers.” Critics would claim this is an obvious error, since everyone knows that Jesus was born in Bethlehem. With the recent discovery of the Amarna letters, there is now a reference to Bethlehem as being in the land of Jerusalem, just as the Book of Mormon says.

7. The name of Alma refers to two prominent men in the Book of Mormon. Some have argued the Alma is not an ancient Semitic man’s name but a Latin woman’s name. So did Joseph make a mistake? Recently an interesting discovery was made by Yigael Yadin, probably the most prominent Israeli archaeologist in this century. While investigating a cave near the Dead Sea, he found a document which bore the name of Alma son of Judah.

How did Joseph with so little education happen to get so many things which we know today are correct?

Time does not permit me to discuss other evidences of the Book of Mormon or the issue of DNA. Nor do I believe that presenting evidence after evidence will prove either that the Bible or the Book of Mormon is true. There are many items in the Bible as well as the Book of Mormon that can’t be “proven” at this time. Perhaps they never will. Perhaps it is by divine purpose the God presents just enough evidence to support but not enough evidence to “prove” that Bible or Book of Mormon is true so that man will trust in the Lord and His Holy spirit rather than the “arm of flesh.” Moroni 10:4-5 provides a test whereby one can know the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon and of all things.

Neil Newbold is a resident of West Jordan, Utah, and reads the Weatherford Democrat online.

Text Only
  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Now is the time for all good men...

    When man’s greed, desire for riches, power and control of our nation become greater than their love of humanity and our country, by constantly fomenting discord and hate among the citizens, warmongering and constantly talking of wars against other nations - it is putting political ideology before the welfare of citizens and country. It is time for We the People to take a good look at these men involved - no matter their status in our nation, we call the United States of America and decide whether or not they deserve the privilege and sanctuary of our nation.

    July 25, 2014

  • tiscione, lou.jpg TISCIONE: Finding a church

    God commands His people to “keep holy the Sabbath Day.” The “Sabbath Day” was changed by the apostolic church to the first day, Sunday. The church refers to every Sunday as the Lord’s Day. Each Lord’s Day is a celebration of the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Therefore, a professing Christian will seek to find a local church in which to invest in the kingdom and worship the King! 

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • John Paul Carter-color.jpg NOTES FROM THE JOURNEY: What’s your current address?

    Shortly after we moved to Weatherford 19 years ago, the old post office (today’s Court Building) that was literally bursting at the seams was replaced by a new, larger facility – our present mail center that sometimes seems outgrown as we stand in line to buy stamps or mail a package.  

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Good company, better service

    We would like to thank Devin’s Handyman Service, Gary Boase, David Schramm and James Reed for the wonderful job they did repainting our front fence, front porch, back porch, patio and deck. Everything looks new and makes such a difference in our home.

    July 23, 2014

  • PASTOR POPHIN: The joy of unity in church

    Do you enjoy going to church? I mean, do you really enjoy going to church? No matter how you answer, there are some common reasons — or perhaps we would call them conditions — that would cause all of us to truly enjoy going to church. 

    July 20, 2014

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Don't judge a book...

    Dear Editor: Thursday night, July 17, I was present for a surprisingly interesting experience when state representative candidate Matthew Britt addressed a small group of supporters, followed by a question and answer session.

    July 20, 2014

  • larry jones cropped:color NOW HEAR THIS: The blessing of memories

    Many years ago, shortly after I retired from the navy, I was sitting around shooting the breeze with my brother David, when he remarked that he regretted never serving in the military and experiencing the things I had seen. Like most of our farmer ancestors, he spent his entire life within five miles of where he grew up. Not unlike our parents, he could also count on the fingers of one hand the number of times he had even been out of the state of Texas and probably have digits to spare.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0912 one bday wm j kelly 2013 mug.jpg KELLY: What do you think?

    Immigration: Wow! Where are all these illegal boys and girls coming from, and why? The “why” is a big question! I’m sure 5-year-olds are not coming for a better life and income. 

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • tiscione, lou.jpg TISCIONE: Signs and seals

    God gave the church signs and seals. These are called sacraments or holy ordinances. They are both holy and commanded. There are two sacraments instituted by Jesus Christ. They are Baptism and the Lord’s Supper. These sacraments are often referred to as “secondary doctrine.” They are secondary not because they are unimportant. They are secondary because they are not necessary for salvation. 

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Response to 'Blame game'

    Dear Editor: It’s not drug cartels telling Central Americans their children won’t be turned away at the border, it is the actions of this administration with its refusal to secure the border and its unilateral rewriting of immigration law. As has been shown, this president and his administration have for some time lied about the security of the border and immigration enforcement.

    July 17, 2014

Must Read
Top News
House Ads
AP Video
Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kerry: No Deal Yet on 7-Day Gaza Truce Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow Gaza Residents Mourn Dead Amid Airstrikes Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground Ohio State Marching Band Chief Fired After Probe Raw: Big Rig Stuck in Illinois Swamp Cumberbatch Brings 'Penguins' to Comic-Con Raw: Air Algerie Crash Site in Mali Power to Be Restored After Wash. Wildfire Crashed Air Algerie Plane Found in Mali Israel Mulls Ceasefire Amid Gaza Offensive In Case of Fire, Oxygen Masks for Pets Mobile App Gives Tour of Battle of Atlanta Sites