Weatherford Democrat

Viewpoints

September 21, 2012

COLUMN: Look to 1930s to assess our own future

— I believe that the only way to predict the future is to study the past. I have recently re-read a historical account of the Great Depression.

I am amazed at how similar the recent great recession is to the Depression. The Great Depression was preceded by three consecutive Republican presidents who believed government had no role in regulating commerce. They all aggressively endorsed the theory that market forces will correct any and all errors or abuses made by corporations and financial institutions. This trust in self-regulation led to the practice of controlling stock shares by putting up as little as 10 percent of the market value of each share. While the investor didn’t actually own the shares, they could profit when share prices increased. This sounded like a great deal to millions of Americans. They could get the profits from a hundred dollars worth of shares, while only risking $10.

The result was unbelievable wealth created on paper, without any corresponding increase in real value. This get rich scheme had one usually undisclosed weakness. If the controlled stock fell in value the investor must increase his cash investment to keep control of the stock. If he failed to meet the so called “margin call” with new cash, he lost his total investment and control of the stock. The whole scheme was based on the premise that stock values would always increase and never decrease.

When stock prices started to decline in 1929 it started an avalanche of stock values returning to their actual value in goods and services. This unstoppable return to reality reduced the value of national wealth by 90 percent. Life savings invested in stocks were completely lost. Banks started to fail, wiping out deposits that were obligated for wages, supplies and creditors. There was no federal depositors insurance, so nothing stopped the financial destruction to individuals and businesses small and large.

Now come forward 70 years to 2008. Republicans again controlled the White House for 20 of the last 28 years. Each president and Congress again enacted laws that deregulated financial institutions based on the premise that market forces would self regulate those institutions. Our own senator Phil Grahm was a champion of deregulation.

The only difference was that instead of speculating in stock, the public was now speculating in real estate, using their homes in another get rich scheme. People bought houses they couldn’t possibly afford, using loans that were programmed to fail in two or three years if the house wasn’t resold at a higher price. Again the scheme was based on the assumption that housing values would increase forever and no matter how great the risk was, the home owner could always sell the house for a profit before the loan payments ballooned or the owner could no longer borrow from other sources to meet living expenses (i.e. credit cards).

In 2005, when a small decrease in housing values occurred, it started an avalanche of loan and bank failures that resulted in a 40 percent decrease in national wealth. Only massive action by the federal government stopped what would have been another decades-long depression. Federal deposit insurance saved bank depositors. The Wall Street bailout stopped the complete destruction of banking and Wall Street. A $800 billion stimulus bill reduced taxes, aided state government and avoided the 25 percent unemployment rate experienced in the 1930s. The resulting political upheavals in 1932 and 2000 are very similar.

In the 1930s, the actions of President Roosevelt and a Democratic Congress could not quickly reverse the damage done, but they definitely stopped the economy from getting any worse. Roosevelt stopped the bank failures and the bleeding of national wealth.

For his efforts, he was accused of being a “Jewish Communist” for regulating Wall Street and banking. He was reviled by so called fiscal conservatives for not being able to quickly clean up the horrible mess they had created. Roosevelt did not end the Depression by increased federal spending, but he greatly reduced the human suffering and prevented the destruction of capitalism and free enterprise in this country.

If you want an example for what could have happened in this country, look at Germany and Italy, which didn’t recognize their people’s degree of suffering during the Depression. These countries didn’t just reject capitalism as a result of the Depression, they replaced democracy. Both countries willingly installed fascist governments headed by the most despicable leaders the world has ever known. In the depths of the Depression if Roosevelt had repudiated the capitalist system and nationalized the banks and corporations, a desperate public would have supported anything that promised improvement.

But there are real differences between America in the 1930s and the 2000s. In the 1930s, people had more realistic expectations. They understood that it takes a lot longer to rebuild a house than it does to burn one down. In the Depression people took heart at any improvement, instead of demanding an impossible quick fix.

But, most of all, the people who speculated in stocks and gambled with money they could not afford to lose, accepted some responsibility for their foolishness. They learned that people who know nothing about finance should not speculate in stocks. They realized they shared responsibility for this disaster and it was going to be a painful recovery.

It took stocks until 1952 to return to the pre-1929 values. It took 14 years for employment to recover, even with the never-seen-before-or-after federal spending of World War II.

What we need to do now is adjust our expectations to reality. We elected presidents and legislators who claimed business didn’t need regulation, even though there is not one example, anywhere in the world, past or present, of successful free enterprise without strict government regulation. We bought the lie that government is the enemy, when in fact it’s the peoples’ only representative at the table where all wealth and power is divided. Without government to regulate and, yes, redistribute wealth and power we end up with feudal capitalism, where there are only two classes, the super wealthy and everyone else.

Capitalism is like our system of highways and roads. It only works when there are enforced traffic laws, which place the safety of the many over the rights of the few to drive as they wish.

1
Text Only
Viewpoints
  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Now is the time for all good men...

    When man’s greed, desire for riches, power and control of our nation become greater than their love of humanity and our country, by constantly fomenting discord and hate among the citizens, warmongering and constantly talking of wars against other nations - it is putting political ideology before the welfare of citizens and country. It is time for We the People to take a good look at these men involved - no matter their status in our nation, we call the United States of America and decide whether or not they deserve the privilege and sanctuary of our nation.

    July 25, 2014

  • tiscione, lou.jpg TISCIONE: Finding a church

    God commands His people to “keep holy the Sabbath Day.” The “Sabbath Day” was changed by the apostolic church to the first day, Sunday. The church refers to every Sunday as the Lord’s Day. Each Lord’s Day is a celebration of the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Therefore, a professing Christian will seek to find a local church in which to invest in the kingdom and worship the King! 

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • John Paul Carter-color.jpg NOTES FROM THE JOURNEY: What’s your current address?

    Shortly after we moved to Weatherford 19 years ago, the old post office (today’s Court Building) that was literally bursting at the seams was replaced by a new, larger facility – our present mail center that sometimes seems outgrown as we stand in line to buy stamps or mail a package.  

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Good company, better service

    We would like to thank Devin’s Handyman Service, Gary Boase, David Schramm and James Reed for the wonderful job they did repainting our front fence, front porch, back porch, patio and deck. Everything looks new and makes such a difference in our home.

    July 23, 2014

  • PASTOR POPHIN: The joy of unity in church

    Do you enjoy going to church? I mean, do you really enjoy going to church? No matter how you answer, there are some common reasons — or perhaps we would call them conditions — that would cause all of us to truly enjoy going to church. 

    July 20, 2014

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Don't judge a book...

    Dear Editor: Thursday night, July 17, I was present for a surprisingly interesting experience when state representative candidate Matthew Britt addressed a small group of supporters, followed by a question and answer session.

    July 20, 2014

  • larry jones cropped:color NOW HEAR THIS: The blessing of memories

    Many years ago, shortly after I retired from the navy, I was sitting around shooting the breeze with my brother David, when he remarked that he regretted never serving in the military and experiencing the things I had seen. Like most of our farmer ancestors, he spent his entire life within five miles of where he grew up. Not unlike our parents, he could also count on the fingers of one hand the number of times he had even been out of the state of Texas and probably have digits to spare.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • 0912 one bday wm j kelly 2013 mug.jpg KELLY: What do you think?

    Immigration: Wow! Where are all these illegal boys and girls coming from, and why? The “why” is a big question! I’m sure 5-year-olds are not coming for a better life and income. 

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • tiscione, lou.jpg TISCIONE: Signs and seals

    God gave the church signs and seals. These are called sacraments or holy ordinances. They are both holy and commanded. There are two sacraments instituted by Jesus Christ. They are Baptism and the Lord’s Supper. These sacraments are often referred to as “secondary doctrine.” They are secondary not because they are unimportant. They are secondary because they are not necessary for salvation. 

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Response to 'Blame game'

    Dear Editor: It’s not drug cartels telling Central Americans their children won’t be turned away at the border, it is the actions of this administration with its refusal to secure the border and its unilateral rewriting of immigration law. As has been shown, this president and his administration have for some time lied about the security of the border and immigration enforcement.

    July 17, 2014

Must Read
Top News
House Ads
AP Video
Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kerry: No Deal Yet on 7-Day Gaza Truce Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow Gaza Residents Mourn Dead Amid Airstrikes Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground Ohio State Marching Band Chief Fired After Probe Raw: Big Rig Stuck in Illinois Swamp Cumberbatch Brings 'Penguins' to Comic-Con Raw: Air Algerie Crash Site in Mali Power to Be Restored After Wash. Wildfire Crashed Air Algerie Plane Found in Mali Israel Mulls Ceasefire Amid Gaza Offensive In Case of Fire, Oxygen Masks for Pets Mobile App Gives Tour of Battle of Atlanta Sites